Earlier this year, a report from industry analysts
at Goldman Sachs predicted we would be looking at oil prices
of $100 a barrel. While a few took the prediction seriously,
many characterized it as mostly a publicity stunt.
Now, with oil futures shooting over $70 per barrel, and Katrina
and refining problems sending prices at the pump to over $3.00
per gallon, the prediction doesn’t look so whacky any
more.
Obviously this impacts our personal wallets, the economy,
Wall Street, etc. But if oil goes to $100 per barrel, and gas
and diesel prices shoot towards $4.00, what are the likely
impacts on supply chain strategy and operations?
Here are some thoughts:
Obviously, transportation and logistics costs are going
up. At $2.00 plus per gallon, we saw fuel surcharges by carriers
of 10-20%. In a Business Week article last April, plumbing
fixture maker Kohler reported it was paying $1 million per
month in fuel charges. At this writing, gas is up about 25%
since then. ABF Freight’s published fuel surcharge at
the beginning of 2005 was 10.4% for LTL freight, and 20.8%
for truckload. The numbers for Aug. 31 were 16.8% and 33.6%.
At these levels, especially if the costs cannot be passed
on to customers, rising transportation costs can have a real
impact on company profitability. At $100 oil, the impact could
be substantial. Are you budgeting and preparing management
for this continued and/or potential spike in transport costs?
Are they being reflected in delivered price quotes being given
to customers? Are you putting in place contracts that for delivered
pricing that include adding your own fuel surcharge in the
event of a continued spike in oil prices?
Raw materials and related supply costs could increase dramatically,
not just due to increased inbound freight costs, but the cost
of energy used in manufacturing and oil-based products, such
as plastics. Already, for example, we’ve seen huge pressure
on many suppliers to the auto industry locked into fixed price
contracts with their customers.
The higher gas prices go, the greater the imperative to unbundle
product and freight costs, and to look for opportunities
to consolidate and save on inbound shipments. Long a goal
of many transportation groups, perhaps the current and continued
spike in fuel prices can be the catalyst to achieve unbundling
in the procurement process. Companies should also be looking
right now at the degree of energy sensitivity in procured
products, and strategizing on alternatives and impact from
$100 oil for these commodities and parts (e.g., at some point
does steel replace plastic?).
The big question I have is how a spike to $100 oil might impact
sourcing, offshoring, and network strategy decisions. At the
heart of network strategy is the balancing of trade-offs across
inventory, transportation and operating costs while meeting
customer service. Almost be definition, the result of that
calculation should be different at $100 oil than it would be
at $30. Would $100 oil, for example, pull back a decision to
offshore certain products when the added cost of transportation
is considered? Would the general (but certainly not universal)
trend towards smaller, more frequent shipments begin to reverse
itself somewhere on the way to $100 oil? At what point am I
better off keeping spare parts inventory in the field versus
express shipping from a master DC?
I recently had a conversation with Wayne Gibson, former VP
of Logistics for Home Depot, and he noted that risk factors
are rarely considered adequately in the sourcing and network
design strategies of most companies. So, for example, few companies
put in a factor that adjusts for the risk of $100 oil (or strikes
at the port) when analyzing the alternatives.
What the current environment and potential $100 oil tells
me most of all is that we need to use more dynamic analyses
of these decisions, use more complex scenario alternatives,
and move from using network design tools from a once every
few years basis to having them baked into a consistent process
of designing and running our supply chains.
I’ve only scratched the surface here.
What do you think the biggest impacts would be to supply chains
from $100 oil? Do we need to be doing more continuous and dynamic
analysis of our supply chain designs and trade-offs?
Let us know your thoughts.
|