SEARCH searchBY TOPIC
right_division Green SCM Distribution
Bookmark us
sitemap
SCDigest Logo
distribution

Focus: Manufacturing

Feature Article from Our Manufacturing Subject Area - See All

From SCDigest's On-Target E-Magazine

- Nov. 10, 2014 -

 
Global Supply Chain News: Look Out China, Here Comes India as Manufacturing Locale of Global Choice

 

Country is Energized under New Prime Minister, Who Vows to Fix Infrastructure and Regulatory Issues; Abbot Labs Opens New Food Plant

 

SCDigest Editorial Staff

Long a disappointment as a potential global sourcing destination, under its new Prime Minister Narendra Modi the country of India is making changes quickly and just might give China and other Asian nations tough competition for production work soon.

Modi won election in May in the most decisive election victory India has seen in three decades, sweeping the long-dominant Congress party from power. He came into the office promising to make India more competitive economically and to turn it into a manufacturing powerhouse - and the results are already being felt.

SCDigest Says:

start

India for now at least has not seen the rapidly rising wages that have dinged China's cost competitiveness a bit in recent years.

close
What Do You Say?

 

Click Here to Send Us Your Comments
feedback
Click Here to See Reader Feedback

Manufacturing in India may not only make sense from a global supply basis, but also well position multi-nationals to make in-roads into India's consumer marketplace, second only to China in terms of population size. Despite its many troubles and vast areas of extreme poverty, India's middle class has still been growing sharply, a pace that might accelerate under Modi's leadership.

Case in point: Abbot Labs. While it had concerns about many aspects of India's infrastructure (electricity, water, roads, etc.), last month the company began production at a $75 million factory in an industrial park in the western state of Gujarat - not a coincidentally the same state that Modi led as governor and oversaw strong economic progress before ascending to national leadership.

The factory is producing Similac baby formula and nutritional supplement PediaSure, which Abbott plans to sell to that the growing Indian middle class. The plant will need about 400 workers by the time it's fully up and running next year. As for India's infrastructure, an Abbot executive e told BusinessWeek that officials in charge of the industrial park where the factory was constructed "were able to deliver very good, very reliable power, water, natural gas, and roads. Fundamentally, the infrastructure was in place."

And Modi plans a lot more of that. Despite labor costs well below that of China, the reputation for lousy infrastructure has been a big barrier to companies looking to India for production. India has also had a bad reputation for burdensome regulations, such as difficulties hiring and firing employees.

And there were high profile incidents, such as the Coca-Cola factory that was ordered closed in June by local government officials, after nearby farmers claimed Coke was "stealing" water from underground aquifers and releasing pollutants into the environment. Coca-Cola disputes both charges, and has almost 60 other bottling operations in India.

On the infrastructure side, for example, the state government of Madhya Pradesh is creating 27 industrial areas for which it promising to improve infrastructure and make labor laws and land acquisition regulations more business-friendly. Modi expects other states to do much the same.

Another advantage India has relates to the historical tensions between Japan and China, recently simmering again in the last few years over disputes about control of islands and ocean space between the two countries.

While Japanese companies opened many production facilities in China, they were also eager for other options, and of late, for example, were making sizable investments in Vietnam. However, Japan recently committed about $35.5 billion in Indian manufacturing development.

BusinessWeek says that "Much of the money will be used to build a giant industrial corridor between Delhi and Mumbai, featuring high-speed trains and superhighways."

(Manufacturing Article Continued Below)

 

CATEGORY SPONSOR: SOFTEON

 


The goal, says Anil Gupta, a professor at the University of Maryland's Robert H. Smith School of Business, is to turn the area into the equivalent of southern China's Guangdong province, which built special economic zones to transform China into an exporting power."

India's Cost Competitiveness

India for now at least has not seen the rapidly rising wages that have dinged China's cost competitiveness a bit in recent years.

Earlier this year, research by the Boston Consulting Group pegged India's manufacturing costs (including several factors beyond just labor) at a score of 87,versus an index level of 100 for current costs to produce in the US. China's score was 9 points higher - at 96 - and moving upward much more rapidly. (See graphic below.) BCG did score India poorly in other areas, such as ease of doing business and corruption levels - exactly the types of problems Modi seems committed to take on.

 

Relative Manufacturing Costs by Country (US = 100)

 

 

Source: Boston Consulting Group

Modi has generated a lot of positive thinking relative to manufacturing inside and outside of India. The country will see 6.3% growth in 2015, and by 2016 the country's growth rate of 7.2% will surpass China's 7.1%, according to CLSA senior economist Rajeev Malik.

India is "the only country that has the scale to take up where China is leaving off," says Frederic Neumann, a senior economist with bank HSBC." Vietnam and Indonesia? "Neither one is big enough to take up the slack," he says


Do you see Indua finally getting its act together in terms of infrasructure and other issues that will make it attractive to multi-nationals? Let us know your thoughts at the Feedback section below.

Recent Feedback

India's new dynamic PM Narendra Modi is certainly very committed to turn India a manufacturing powerhouse. He does seem very passionate about the country's progress and is taking steps in the right direction. A vast majority of India's young population is for the first time in many years supporting a political leader with such zeal. I know I certainly do. 


With all this being said, there is one major problem that might take years and serious efforts to change is corrpution. Corruption is prevalent everywhere and nothing get done in India without that. If one needs to eradicate corrpuition, the laws of the country need to be very strict. Everyone needs to be made accountable for their actions which does not happen in India. Everyone with power and money gets aways with anything - even murder. Once all this is taken care of, there will be no stopping and India will be the fastest growing economy in the world. 


 


Malika Wadhwani
Digital Marketing Manager
ATC (Argo Turboserve Corporation)
Nov, 11 2014

I will believe it when I see it.  The issue is not transplant businesses being put in with sufficient resources.  The issue is the culture which has no sense of urgency.  Every launch I have been associated with India has been late and over budget.  I was with a teir 1 Automotive suppler and I had PPAP parts and they still did not reach required output for 1 year.  Danaher a leader in operations management efficiency shifted stepper motor production from Malaysia to India.  I was without any product for 5 months because of the plant relocation.  If I had not engaged a Chinese manufacturer, my line would have been down the entire time.


John Reeder
Manager Global Supply Chain
TransAct Technologies Inc.
Nov, 13 2014
 
.
.