SEARCH searchBY TOPIC
right_division Green SCM Distribution
Bookmark us
sitemap
SCDigest Logo
distribution

Focus: Sourcing/Procurement: Feature Article from Our Sourcing and Procurement Subject Area - See All

From SCDigest's On-Target e-Magazine

- Oct. 13, 2015 -

 
Supply Chain News: Using a Negotiations Spreadsheet Tool can Help Procurement Managers Work More Effectively with Business Managers

Alexandra Moschell of Hallmark Discusses Her Approach in Inside Supply Management

 

SDigest Editorial Staff 

 

Can a simple spreadsheet tool help procurement manager communicate with their internal business partners and drive more clarity relative to goals for negotiations with suppliers?

SCDigest Says:

start

Moschell says it is often beneficial to conduct a preparation meeting with the business partner and SME team prior to each negotiation to build confidence in the process, and to confirm roles and responsibilities.

 

Accenture

close
What Do You Say?
Click Here to Send Us Your Comments
feedback
Click Here to See Reader Feedback

Alexandra Moschell, senior strategic buyer for Hallmark Cards, thinks so, so much that she wrote about the approach in a recent edition of the Inside Supply Management magazine from the Institute for Supply Management.

Moschell says the development of a negotiations strategy consists of four key steps:

Communicate: Start with a kick-off meeting with the business partner(s) in which information is shared relative to the process, roles, and a basic time table. The conversation should also document what will constitute successin a particular negotiation.

Moschell also belies that when this information is openly discussed, business managers "may not be compelled to conduct the negotiations independently when they know that procurement is going to effectively represent their goals and interests."

Prepare and Analyze: In this phase, procurement managers can start populating the spreadsheet tool (see example below).

That includes adding key negotiating points, background information in the notes section, and documenting all the issues and their importance to the business partner in order of priority.

Also documented is the partner's likely objective for each negotiating point.

"With the knowledge of what the business partner is trying to achieve, you can develop a targeted strategy to obtain each objective," Moschell writes.

And don't fail to ask what information business partners know about a supplier. This shows respect, and they often do know quite a bit about a given supplier's business that will help in developing the strategy.

At this point, the procurement manager further completes the spreadsheet tool: Negotiation, Objective, Strategy to Obtain Objective, and Outcome/Status.

Once these fields are populated, each negotiation item should be ranked in order of importance.

 

Hallmark's Negotiations Summary Tool

 

 

Source: Alexandra Moschell, in Inside Supply Management


"Document all the requirements to achieve a beneficial outcome, which will make the strategy more intuitive and easy to follow," Moschell adds. "It also will allow you to effectively plan rebuttals and counters to the supplier's objections, now knowing what is important to the supplier, where to push and where to concede."

After the populated template is complete, the next step is to meet with the business partner(s) to share the documented process. This is the time to discuss whether the plan as documented is consistent with the goals agreed on at the kick-off meeting.


(Sourcing and Procurement Article Continues Below)

CATEGORY SPONSOR: SOFTEON

 

"Once your business partner becomes familiar with the planning tool, you can meet quickly to review the document and make necessary adjustments," Moschell says.

Plan the Negotiation: Key points to follow include defining who should be present at the negotiations (subject matter experts, for example), where and when the meetings will take place, the right format of the meeting, and other basics.

Moschell says it is often beneficial to conduct a preparation meeting with the business partner and SME team prior to each negotiation to build confidence in the process, and to confirm roles and responsibilities.

Following each negotiation, the tool is used to document the outcome in the column associated with the negotiation point. Then procurement should meet with the business partner to review what was achieved in the negotiation and what is still unresolved.

Create a Summary: Moschell also recommends that once the negotiation is complete and the key objectives of the business partner have been met, the procurement manager should create a one-page executive summary, in parallel asking if the business partner is pleased with this outcome or if further negotiations are needed on any points.

"I've found that by creating this summary, my business partner has fewer day-to-day questions about the agreement and can easily look up a key element for quick review of where we landed on a particular point," Moschell writes.

In summary, Moschell also notes that "A negotiation strategy tool offers visibility to all participants and clearly documents outcomes, demonstrating the important role supply management plays in negotiating contracts."

What do you think of this simple negotiating tool? What kind of tool have you found works well? Let us know your thoughts at the Feedback button (email) or section (web form) below.



Recent Feedback

This fits in with Debono and problem solving conflict resolution approaches. 

I look forward to any assitance with my company registred in Texas and doing business across Africa, USA and Canada? 

 


Richard Unite
Development Manager
Madiba.com
Feb, 22 2021
 
.